The first taste of this new era we heard was the bombastic lead single, Bloom Baby Bloom. The song is showy dramatic piece of piano-led glam rock, with Ellie Rowsell's soaring vocals gliding above a rollicking piano riff and snappy percussion. So it was pretty evident that the rest of the record would be leaning into the 70's rock revival that the indie scene has been obsessed with over the past year or so. As much as a like the song, I was a little worried for the album as a whole; as I'm not the biggest fan of Kurstin's production in general (particularly when it comes to more indie leaning acts) and Bloom Baby Bloom, while it does sound great, it is rather clean and shiny for a band known for their noisy, layered songs and fuzzed out guitars.
I'm glad to say that Kurstin hasn't butchered the production here (the opener, Thorns, is the only real offender of the dreaded 'pop producer throws in everything and the kitchen sink' cliché with it's unearned swells of strings, and excessive multitracked and tremolo effected vocals), but he doesn't really excel at it either. The record on the whole sounds way too clean and sterile, lacking the organic warmth and intimacy of the sounds and styles it is calling back to. It feels like the big budget, Hollywood, focus-tested version of a 70's throwback record - which is essentially what it is. I think the problem with this is that the songwriting is also a bit hit and miss (which is quite unexpected for Wolf Alice), meaning that the weaker songs here just breeze by without any interesting production to draw attention to them.
Where the record really excels is in its singles. Just Two Girls follows Bloom Baby Bloom in the tracklist and is one of the most lyrically detailed songs on the record. The song is a heartfelt ode to female friendship (completing a trilogy of songs including Bros and Beautifully Unconventional). It's lyrically dense and witty, yet subtly catchy with groovy piano riff and little variations on the vocal melody throughout the song. The album then closes out with the other two singles, White Horses and The Sofa. White Horses is a driving, jangly, somewhat folky indie rock tune that builds up in layers to a cacophony of sound. It is probably the closest to the band's typical walls of sound that The Clearing gets and is appreciated after and album that is generally pretty mellow throughout. The Sofa, on the other hand, is a rich, cinematic, string-laden ballad to close out the record and its themes. Ellie soulfully croons about finding peace in herself and accepting the duality of wanting to be the dramatic, sexy rock frontwoman that she has often portrayed herself as in the band's previous output; and to be the chill, laid-back 'clean girl' who just wants to 'lay on the sofa' and take life at a slower pace. All three of these songs are excellent and stand up with the rest of the band's catalogue.
Unfortunately The Clearing starts to falter in the deep cuts, that are all concentrated in the middle of the record. I like the subtle jangle of Leaning Against The Wall, and it's initial tale of running into an ex long after the breakup when all the pain has subsided. But the song very quickly hits a lyrical dead end as Ellie doesn't really go much further into the encounter beyond a few cliché remarks, and the song also barely has a chorus. It definitely feels like the song needed more time in the oven. Similarly, Play It Out has some interesting ideas around aging and motherhood, but is wrapped up in a slow piano ballad where the instrumental is frankly quite plain and boring. Passenger Seat is a pretty perfunctory soft rock tune. It's perfectly fine while it's on, but there are a thousand songs that sound exactly like it and explore similar themes of escape and 'running away with the person you love'. I have similar feelings about Safe In the World, which for me is the most unremarkable song in the tracklist. Bread Butter Tea Sugar is another song that has elements I really like (the more dramatic, glam rock aesthetic and more commanding vocals from Ellie), but once again feels kind of kneecapped by the production. The groove feels very stiff and rigid, and lacks the swagger and arrogance that this kind of glam rock song needs. The only deep cut that I think hits the mark in all elements is the dreamy, layered up chamber folk track, Midnight Song. It's the kind of song that the band has pulled off before so it is right in their wheelhouse. It is also one of the few moments where the warmth and texture of the record shines through the production; and Ellie's vocals remind me of the likes of Nico, adding to the throwback vibe.
There is some great stuff on The Clearing, and some tunes that are going to be Wolf Alice Staples in years to come. But it is weirdly inconsistent for a band that has never been inconsistent, even back to their earliest EPs. That combined with just the wrong choice in producer, results in an album that while has its moments, doesn't come together to anything particularly impactful. I don't see myself in a couple of years regularly putting this on like I do with the rest of the discography, and I'll probably only listen to it in future when I'm just having a Wolf Alice binge and listening through the whole discography. It's a bit of a shame, but I think it's just a misfire and the band will probably go and do something completely different again for album 5.
Top Tracks: Bloom Baby Bloom, Just Two Girls, Midnight Song, White Horses, The Sofa
6/10
No comments:
Post a Comment