Foo Fighters - "But Here We Are" (2023)

The 2010's were very much a victory lap for the Foos, basically becoming permanent stadium sell-outs and festival headliners, and the records definitely reflected that - being mostly mediocre re-treads that didn't try too hard (or even need to) as an excuse to go back out on the road again so thousands of people can chant the Everlong riff back at the band in muddy fields across the world. But as the band were touring during 2022, the groups longtime drummer Tayler Hawkins suddenly passed away. The same year, Dave Grohl's mother, Virginia also passed away, and so But Here We Are is explicitly about and dedicated to two of the most important people in Dave's life. 

The record is a cathartic expression of grief but also a hopeful celebration of life in that typically anthemically optimistic Foo Fighters way. From the opening thunderous drumming (Grohl has taken up recording duties for the drums with Josh Freese joining life) and crashing guitars of Rescued has Grohl howls "It came in a flash, it came out of nowhere", you know this is the kind of album to belt your heart out with 10,000 people in a muddy field. The fuzzed out powerpop chords of Under You recall the scrappier, punkier side of the band from the earlier years with some really heartfelt and passionate lyrics about not being to get over what's happened but being hopeful that one day he'll "Come out from under you".

The two opening tracks were the two lead singles, an usually for Foos they're the two best songs on the record and the rest is varying degrees of filler. But on But Hear We Are, the deep cuts are all remarkably solid. Hearing Voices has a super moody and reverby verse section that's reminiscent of The Cure's arena ready songs off Wish. Show Me How is a really restrained and tense duet with Dave's daughter, Violet. She is a phenomenal singer (check out her performance of Jeff Buckley's Grace at the Taylor Hawkins tribute concert last year) and she brings such a different vibe to Foo's typical style. Nothing At All starts of with a chiming guitar and drums pattern before the the roaring guitars and Dave's growl slaps you round the face in the chorus. The lyrics focusing around the self destructive feelings of nihilism and recklessness following a significant loss do really hit hard. The track also has such pit-worthy breakdown and climax.

The record closes out with two very unique songs for the Foos, the first being the 10 minute, linear, multi-section The Teacher. This song is probably the best song on the record, progressing through various moody, lowkey sections laden in effects, to soaring typically Foos chorus sections, to anthemic sections accompanied by ornate strings. The track repeats through these sections with the tempo picking up each time, before the track burns itself out and returns to the brooding moodiness for the final leg. The closer, Rest, starts out as an acoustic cut reprising the melody from Under You, feeling like the record coming full circle. But the guitars crash in about half way through and become increasingly more distorted until its basically a wall of sound by the end of the song. I think it perfectly represents the themes of the record, as in it doesn't end all neatly and nicely, and that you don't just wake up one day and you are over such a massive loss like this.

Unfortunately, the record does have a major flaw that hold it back from being a really really great record, being the production. For some reason the band has decided to mix it so incredibly loud and compressed. Despite being one of the most dynamic records in their discography, the mixing blows everything out so that the quieter moments don't have the space they need and the louder songs can be downright suffocating. The worst offender is the title track, where Dave's iconic scream is somehow fighting to be heard above the guitars and pummelling drums. It's a song I would otherwise really like, but is actually kind of ruined by the production. It's really strange, cause despite how loud and brash the band can be, they've never really had this issue before.

I'm not a Foos superfan, so I couldn't give you an honest ranking of their albums. But this is the first one in a long while that feels like a complete whole and not just a vehicle for a couple of singles and to go out on tour again. Out of the ones I have heard in full, it might even be their best (I know its apparently sacrilege to say anything other than The Colour And The Shape is their best). If it wasn't so compressed, and had a couple more top tier songs instead of The Glass and Beyond Me (they're perfectly fine songs but are very run of the mill Foos compared to the rest of the record), it'd be a truly great record.

Top Tracks: Rescued, Under You, Hearing Voices, Nothing At All, Show Me How, The Teacher, Rest

7/10