That lead single is titled This is the Killer Speaking, and was one of the new songs played by the band when I saw them on tour. Musically and lyrically, it picks up right where Prelude To Ecstasy left off. It is a glammy and over-the-top pop rock banger telling the tale of a scorned lover out to get revenge on their ex. While the debut's lyrics were a bit more fiery and pointed, This Is The Killer Speaking leans more into the camp and it works. Not every song has to be pointed critique of patriarchal dynamics within society. The other song they played live was also one of the pre-release singles, being Second Best. The song is about exactly what it says on the tin, walking away from someone who treats you like you're second best. The track leans into the band's Sparks influence, having dramatic staccato vocal passages and a punchy rhythm section. The song just builds and builds into a frenzied climax and is easily my favourite song on the record.
The rest of From The Pyre really follows on from those songs, being just more of what made the first album great. On a musical level, the only really distinguishing feature is the switch from James Ford to Markus Dravs as producer, resulting in the strings taking a little more of a backseat on these tracks, replaced with punchier, more prominent guitars in the mix. Similarly, lyrically the band are playing around with a lot of the same ideas and themes as the debut, but in a less tight and cohesive way. All of the tracks on PTE reinforced one another in a way that I don't think they do as well here. The opener, Agnus Dei, revolves around desire and not feeling good enough for someone, comparing it to Catholic mass and the apocalypse. The song is good opener, with Abigail Morris' dynamic vocals and lush instrumentation; but if the song was packaged as part of a deluxe version of the debut I wouldn't have batted an eyelid.
Count The Ways feels a bit more distinct, featuring the more guitar heavy mixing I mentioned previously. Once again, the band are exploring themes of tortured love and wanting to stay with someone who is 'twisting the knife'. Rifle feels like a mid-2000s Muse track, with heavy use of loud-soft chorus-verse dynamics and pentatonic scales. The song explores the male desire for violence and killing; but unlike past songs where they've touched on these subjects, it's approached from a less feminine / romantic angle, but a more 'above it all' parental viewpoint. It's certainly an interesting perspective from the band; and I wish the song had bit more of a hook to go with it - because it isn't the most melodically developed song on the record and is sort of compensating with the brash guitars choral backing vocals.
Woman is a Tree kicks of the second half with a nice change of pace for the band, being a spooky, dramatic, folk tune. It sounds like some culty campfire tune - again with engaging themes around comparing womanhood to be a strong and stable tree that provides nourishment to those around it. I Hold Your Anger follows this up with a song that feels pretty run of the mill for the band at this point. The song is sung by the Keyboardist Aurora Nishevci rather than Abigail, which is the songs most unique element. Otherwise it's a fairly dramatic glam rock cut about a woman holding everything together in a relationship. Sail Away, similarly, is musically a pretty bog standard piano ballad that doesn't really grab me. I think the lyrics are pretty good, but they're wrapped up in an instrumental that I think is merely just fine.
The Scythe is the real showstopper of the second half. The song was originally written by Abigail years ago as a breakup song, but has morphed into a more general song about grief and loss overall. It is an absolutely massive sounding power-ballad with twinkling keys, a vintage 80's sounding drumbeat and layers upon layers of background strings and organs. Abigail wails the lyrics on the chorus "Don't cry, we're bound together / Each life runs its course" with so much passion and power it's hard not to feel some sort of emotive response to it. It's a shame that the closer, Inferno, follows this up with a bit of a dud. The song is a jangly indie rock song with subtle glam rock touches, but it really doesn't pay off the emotional weight of The Scythe and feels like a bit an unsatisfying way to end the record if I'm being honest.
From The Pyre is very much more of what worked on Prelude To Ecstasy. There are some genuinely great cuts on the album that are fine additions to the band's canon. However it does feel a little second album syndrome-y, with a couple of moments that feel like the band treading water and on the whole not feeling quite as tight and cohesive as the debut. I hope that with a couple of albums under their belt and being big names in British indie now, they can take just a little bit longer to craft album 3 into something with its own unique identity.
Top Tracks: Agnus Dei, Count The Ways, Second Best, This is the Killer Speaking, Woman is a Tree, The Scythe
7/10
