While I regularly come back to pretty much all of the band's releases up to and including Wish, the following 4 records the band released in the late 90s and 2000s are considered a significant step down be me and many others. It felt like Robert Smith and Co. were just running out of steam; either rehashing their past glories or bringing half-arsed and shallow gimmicks to the table in the place of genuine inspiration. This all cumulated in 2008's 4:13 Dream; and while better than the preceding album (2004's self titled, and baffling mess of a record that for some reason the group got nu-metal super producer Ross Robinson to produce), it was essentially a complete damp squib of a record that sounded more like a touched up b-sides compilation than anything genuinely inspired or meaningful.
And then nothing... for 11 years. Smith did suggest for a while that a sequel album to 4:13 would be released featuring other songs from those sessions, but that never materialised. The band essentially became a touring legacy act during the 2010s (which resulted in some excellent live albums). Then in 2019, Robert announced that a new album would be on its way that very year - which didn't happen. The years rolled by again, with Smith promising it was still coming but with nothing to show. By the time 2022 rolled around with the band on a tour literally named after this album (Shows Of A Lost World) and it still wasn't out, I had given up hope that we were ever going to hear this album. So when the opening cut, Alone, was dropped by the band at the end of September as the lead single for the album, and it was easily the best song they had released in 30 years, I was beyond exited to hear the full thing.
In some ways, Alone is vintage Cure: the long drawn out intro, the slow and steady bassline and Smith's melancholic vocals. In others, it feels more Cocteau Twins than The Cure. The piercing, reverb-gated drums and skittering, reverby synth effects create this disorientating and otherworldly atmosphere; and the whole mix is close and claustrophobic. Lyrically, while certainly in keeping with bands previous work, it does tread new water for the group. The song quite overtly deals in the themes of mortality, death and facing the end of times in a very stark and raw way. Shaped by the deaths of his parents and older brother, and Smith facing his own aging and mortality; Songs Of A Lost World is more upfront and raw than the bands previous 'doom and gloom' records, set to really dense and claustrophobic instrumentation and production.
The second single, A Fragile Thing is a more typically radio friendly single for the record with its higher tempo and catchy chorus. It's still very dark, with Smith describing the song as a flipside to their classic track Lovesong. Where that track was literally a wedding present from Smith to his wife (and a moment of hope within the darkness of Disintegration), A Fragile Thing is about how fragile and all consuming love is. The momentum of the track is carried by rigid, staccato hits of piano that gives the effect of a timer ticking down to inevitable doom.
The middle of the record is occupied by the two 'rockiest' cuts of the album, Warsong and Drone:Nodrone. Warsong slowly builds and builds though its drawn out intro, where thundrous blown out drums clatter against roaring guitars. When Smith's vocals finally come in, he sounds like prophet of the apocalypse, howling about humanity's innate desire to hate and to fight and to kill. The song is deeply nihilistic and presented in such an immense, monolithic context. Drone:Nodrone on the other hand is a song about complete and utter bewilderment. It inspired by a drone flying above Smith one day and making him feel like a man out of time who doesn't connect with the modern world around him. The song has a bit more of a groove than the rest of the album, and spacy synths which calls back to the band's excursions into alt dance and baggy from the early 90s. The disorientating, spiralling keyboards and whining lead guitars also give off a vibe similar to the heavier stadium rock songs from Wish.
The album descends deeper into the darkness in the second half, starting the with the really quite harrowing I Can Never Say Goodbye. The song is a slow and stark ballad directly referencing the death of Robert's Brother. The dense, claustrophobic production that characterises the rest of album makes way for more space to allow the pain and grief in Smith's words to sink in. All I Ever Am dials the intensity back up with clattering, pummelling percussion, sirenning synths and crunchy bass as Robert confronts his own mortality, beliefs and regrets. This leads into the ten and a half minute behemoth of a closer, Endsong. The song slowly builds through its six and a half minute intro before Smith's vocals finally come in. The song has an immense sense of finality to it and is the perfect way to wrap up the record. Robert is promising that another Cure record will be on its way soon, but if that doesn't happen Endsong (and the record as a whole) is a fitting book end to the band's discography.
The main critique that the album has been receiving by some is that the production is a little bricked out. And while I don't agree with this for most of the album (I feel like the production creates this oppressive, suffocating feeling), the second track And Nothing Is Forever does feel a bit unbalanced. Everything in the high end of the mix (Smith's vocals, the synths, the guitars) feel like they're fighting for space, while the low end (bass and drums) seems really set back and distant. It does lessen my enjoyment of an otherwise great cut.
Songs Of A Lost World has achieved something that the band hasn't managed to in 30 years - it's a concise, focused record with something really meaningful to say. Smith has always written about death, impending doom and the destruction of the things in life he holds dear; but here he is coming from a much more grounded and real-world angle. Faith and Pornography are records obsessed with grotesque imagery and the angry nihilism of youth. Disintegration is a yearning and romantic under it's apocalyptic imagery. SOALW is Smith staring down the barrel of the gun with no façade, no pretence.
Top Tracks: Alone, A Fragile Thing, Warsong, Drone:Nodrone, I Can Never Say Goodbye, All I Ever Am, Endsong
9/10